Yamada Translation Bureau, Inc.
  • ホーム
  • Home
  • 会社情報
    • 会社概要
    • 事業所
    • 品質/情報セキュリティ
    • コンプライアンス
  • About Us
    • Profile
    • Offices
    • QMS/ ISMS
    • Compliance
  • サービス
    • 翻訳
    • 医学論文添削
  • Services
    • Translation
    • Manuscript editing / proofreading
    • FAQ >
      • FAQ(Translation)
      • FAQ(Edit)
  • お問合わせ
    • お問合わせ/ご注文
    • FAQ >
      • FAQ(翻訳サービス)
      • FAQ(論文添削サービス)
    • 登録翻訳者・翻訳チェッカー募集
  • Contact us
  • お客様の声
  • Testimonials

Responding to reviewers

Addressing each issue

1/28/2019

1 コメント

 
Picture
This is the most important point.
It is essential to address each issue raised by the editor and reviewers. Even if you consider that a request is impossible, or unreasonable, or just wrong, you need to mention it in your reply letter and explain your thinking about it.
If you don’t mention all the points that were raised, they are unlikely to ignore omissions. Your manuscript will probably be returned and you will be asked to submit another revision.

To address each issue, you first need to identify all of them. This is sometimes easy because thoughtful reviewers will give you a numbered list of points to respond to, or will set out their questions clearly in some other way.
Unfortunately, many reviewers jam all of their questions and comments together. Then you have to try and disentangle them. Here is a typical example of a letter from that type of reviewer, which I  have devised.  (See Example 1)

1 コメント

    Author

    Write something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview.

    Archives

    1月 2019

    Categories

    すべて

    RSSフィード

会社方針
医学論文のヒント
企業方針
​情報セキュリティ方針
​
品質方針
​
個人情報の取り扱い
​
サイトポリシー
Dr.McQuireの英語医薬論文の鍵
Dr.McQuireのメディカルライティング教室
​査読者に対する回答の書き方
​医療統計教室
​

blog

Jeffの言葉と文化のとらえ方
信息安全政策         品质方针          网站政策


Picture
Company Policy
ISMS Policy
Quality Policy
Privacy Policy
Site Policy
  • ホーム
  • Home
  • 会社情報
    • 会社概要
    • 事業所
    • 品質/情報セキュリティ
    • コンプライアンス
  • About Us
    • Profile
    • Offices
    • QMS/ ISMS
    • Compliance
  • サービス
    • 翻訳
    • 医学論文添削
  • Services
    • Translation
    • Manuscript editing / proofreading
    • FAQ >
      • FAQ(Translation)
      • FAQ(Edit)
  • お問合わせ
    • お問合わせ/ご注文
    • FAQ >
      • FAQ(翻訳サービス)
      • FAQ(論文添削サービス)
    • 登録翻訳者・翻訳チェッカー募集
  • Contact us
  • お客様の声
  • Testimonials